ProtoLedger Terminal
Interactive blockchain ranking by Monetary Fitness (M) and System Soundness (S)
UNCALIBRATED — awaiting v4 re-assessment
Layer C filters (show only assets matching a disclosure)
privacy_posture — Privacy Posture
identity_model — Identity Model
issuance_ethic — Issuance Ethic
consensus_cost — Consensus Cost
governance_model — Governance Model
autonomy_accountability — Autonomy Accountability
jurisdictional_posture — Jurisdictional Posture
catastrophic_failure_modes — Catastrophic Failure Modes
Property weights (0 = exclude · 5 = highest weight)
Layer A — Monetary Fitness
Layer B — System Soundness
| Chain | M/10 | S/10 | A1 | A2 | A3 | A4 | A5 | A6 | A7 | B1 | B2 | B3 | B4 | B5 | B6 | B7 | B8 | B9 | B10 | Flags |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| USDC USDC | 7.3 | 5.2 |
9Acceptability & Liquidity 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Value Stability 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Usability & Safety 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Portability & Divisibility 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Fungibility 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Recognizability 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Cost Efficiency & Capacity 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Supply Integrity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Settlement Assurance 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
1No Single Point of Control 1/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Rule Auditability 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Forward Security Margin 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6No Invisible Rent 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Resource Proportionality 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
B1/B2<7
privacy_posture: Transparent
identity_model: Pseudonymous (KYC at ramps)
issuance_ethic: Reserve-backed / discretionary
consensus_cost: Inherits host chain
governance_model: Institutional (Circle)
autonomy_accountability: High accountability (freeze authority)
|
| Tether USDT | 7.3 | 5.0 |
9Acceptability & Liquidity 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Value Stability 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Usability & Safety 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Portability & Divisibility 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Fungibility 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Recognizability 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Cost Efficiency & Capacity 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Supply Integrity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Settlement Assurance 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
1No Single Point of Control 1/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Rule Auditability 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Forward Security Margin 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6No Invisible Rent 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Resource Proportionality 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
B1/B2<7
privacy_posture: Transparent
identity_model: Pseudonymous (KYC at ramps)
issuance_ethic: Reserve-backed / discretionary
consensus_cost: Inherits host chain
governance_model: Institutional (issuer)
autonomy_accountability: High accountability (freeze authority)
|
| Dai DAI | 6.9 | 6.6 |
7Acceptability & Liquidity 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Value Stability 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Usability & Safety 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Portability & Divisibility 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Fungibility 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Recognizability 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Cost Efficiency & Capacity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Supply Integrity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Settlement Assurance 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6No Single Point of Control 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Rule Auditability 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Forward Security Margin 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5No Invisible Rent 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Resource Proportionality 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
B1/B2<7
privacy_posture: Transparent
identity_model: Pseudonymous
issuance_ethic: Collateral rule-bound
consensus_cost: Inherits Ethereum
governance_model: On-chain vote (Sky/Maker)
autonomy_accountability: Moderate (USDC-collateral dependency)
|
| Solana SOL | 6.4 | 5.9 |
7Acceptability & Liquidity 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Value Stability 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Usability & Safety 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Portability & Divisibility 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Fungibility 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Recognizability 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Cost Efficiency & Capacity 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Supply Integrity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Settlement Assurance 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5No Single Point of Control 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Rule Auditability 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Forward Security Margin 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4No Invisible Rent 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Resource Proportionality 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
B1/B2<7
privacy_posture: Transparent
identity_model: Pseudonymous
issuance_ethic: Rule-bound elastic
consensus_cost: Proof-of-Stake
governance_model: On-chain + foundation
autonomy_accountability: Moderate autonomy
|
| Bitcoin BTC | 6.1 | 8.1 |
8Acceptability & Liquidity 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Value Stability 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Usability & Safety 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Portability & Divisibility 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Fungibility 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Recognizability 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Cost Efficiency & Capacity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
10Supply Integrity 10/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Settlement Assurance 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
10Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 10/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
10No Single Point of Control 10/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Rule Auditability 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Forward Security Margin 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8No Invisible Rent 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Resource Proportionality 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
privacy_posture: Transparent (pseudonymous)
identity_model: Pseudonymous
issuance_ethic: Fixed cap
consensus_cost: Proof-of-Work
governance_model: Ossified
autonomy_accountability: High autonomy
|
| Monero XMR | 6.1 | 7.3 |
5Acceptability & Liquidity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Value Stability 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Usability & Safety 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Portability & Divisibility 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
10Fungibility 10/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Recognizability 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Cost Efficiency & Capacity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Supply Integrity 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Settlement Assurance 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9No Single Point of Control 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Rule Auditability 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Forward Security Margin 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7No Invisible Rent 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Resource Proportionality 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
A1<7
privacy_posture: Total untraceability (mandatory)
identity_model: Anonymous
issuance_ethic: Rule-bound (tail emission)
consensus_cost: PoW (RandomX)
governance_model: Off-chain / community
autonomy_accountability: High autonomy
|
| Zcash ZEC | 6.1 | 7.0 |
5Acceptability & Liquidity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Value Stability 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Usability & Safety 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Portability & Divisibility 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
10Fungibility 10/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Recognizability 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Cost Efficiency & Capacity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Supply Integrity 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Settlement Assurance 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8No Single Point of Control 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Rule Auditability 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Forward Security Margin 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7No Invisible Rent 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Resource Proportionality 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
A1<7
privacy_posture: Optional shielded (fungibility-grade)
identity_model: Pseudonymous/anonymous
issuance_ethic: Fixed cap
consensus_cost: Proof-of-Work
governance_model: Off-chain + foundation
autonomy_accountability: High autonomy
|
| Stellar XLM | 6.1 | 5.9 |
5Acceptability & Liquidity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Value Stability 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Usability & Safety 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Portability & Divisibility 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Fungibility 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Recognizability 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Cost Efficiency & Capacity 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Supply Integrity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Settlement Assurance 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4No Single Point of Control 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Rule Auditability 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Forward Security Margin 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6No Invisible Rent 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Resource Proportionality 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
A1<7
B1/B2<7
privacy_posture: Transparent
identity_model: Pseudonymous
issuance_ethic: Pre-allocated (fixed)
consensus_cost: SCP (federated)
governance_model: Institutional (SDF)
autonomy_accountability: Accountability-leaning
|
| Dogecoin DOGE | 6.1 | 5.8 |
5Acceptability & Liquidity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
2Value Stability 2/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Usability & Safety 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Portability & Divisibility 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Fungibility 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Recognizability 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Cost Efficiency & Capacity 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Supply Integrity 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Settlement Assurance 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6No Single Point of Control 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Rule Auditability 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Forward Security Margin 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7No Invisible Rent 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Resource Proportionality 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
A1<7
B1/B2<7
privacy_posture: Transparent
identity_model: Pseudonymous
issuance_ethic: Unbounded tail inflation
consensus_cost: PoW (merge-mined)
governance_model: Ossified / minimal
autonomy_accountability: High autonomy
|
| XRP XRP | 6.1 | 5.4 |
6Acceptability & Liquidity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Value Stability 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Usability & Safety 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Portability & Divisibility 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Fungibility 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Recognizability 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Cost Efficiency & Capacity 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Supply Integrity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Settlement Assurance 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4No Single Point of Control 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Rule Auditability 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Forward Security Margin 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5No Invisible Rent 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Resource Proportionality 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
A1<7
B1/B2<7
privacy_posture: Transparent
identity_model: Pseudonymous
issuance_ethic: Pre-allocated + escrow
consensus_cost: RPCA (federated)
governance_model: Institutional (Ripple-influenced)
autonomy_accountability: Accountability-leaning
|
| World Liberty USD1 USD1 | 6.1 | 4.8 |
6Acceptability & Liquidity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Value Stability 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Usability & Safety 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Portability & Divisibility 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Fungibility 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Recognizability 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Cost Efficiency & Capacity 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Supply Integrity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Settlement Assurance 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
1No Single Point of Control 1/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Rule Auditability 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Forward Security Margin 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6No Invisible Rent 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
2Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 2/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Resource Proportionality 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
A1<7
B1/B2<7
privacy_posture: Transparent
identity_model: Pseudonymous (KYC at ramps)
issuance_ethic: Reserve-backed / discretionary
consensus_cost: Inherits host chains
governance_model: Institutional (WLFI/BitGo)
autonomy_accountability: Very high accountability (froze addresses Jun 2026)
|
| Ethereum ETH | 6.0 | 7.1 |
8Acceptability & Liquidity 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Value Stability 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Usability & Safety 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Portability & Divisibility 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Fungibility 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Recognizability 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Cost Efficiency & Capacity 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Supply Integrity 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Settlement Assurance 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8No Single Point of Control 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Rule Auditability 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Forward Security Margin 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4No Invisible Rent 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Resource Proportionality 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
privacy_posture: Transparent
identity_model: Pseudonymous
issuance_ethic: Rule-bound elastic
consensus_cost: Proof-of-Stake
governance_model: Off-chain / foundation
autonomy_accountability: Moderate autonomy
|
| TRON TRX | 6.0 | 5.1 |
6Acceptability & Liquidity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Value Stability 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Usability & Safety 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Portability & Divisibility 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Fungibility 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Recognizability 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Cost Efficiency & Capacity 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Supply Integrity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Settlement Assurance 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3No Single Point of Control 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Rule Auditability 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Forward Security Margin 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4No Invisible Rent 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Resource Proportionality 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
A1<7
B1/B2<7
privacy_posture: Transparent
identity_model: Pseudonymous
issuance_ethic: Issuer-influenced
consensus_cost: DPoS
governance_model: Institutional (Sun-influenced)
autonomy_accountability: Accountability-leaning
|
| BNB BNB | 6.0 | 5.0 |
6Acceptability & Liquidity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Value Stability 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Usability & Safety 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Portability & Divisibility 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Fungibility 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Recognizability 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Cost Efficiency & Capacity 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Supply Integrity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Settlement Assurance 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3No Single Point of Control 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Rule Auditability 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Forward Security Margin 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4No Invisible Rent 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Resource Proportionality 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
A1<7
B1/B2<7
privacy_posture: Transparent
identity_model: Pseudonymous
issuance_ethic: Rule-bound + burns
consensus_cost: PoS (BNB Chain)
governance_model: Institutional (Binance)
autonomy_accountability: Accountability-leaning
|
| Cardano ADA | 5.9 | 6.8 |
5Acceptability & Liquidity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Value Stability 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Usability & Safety 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Portability & Divisibility 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Fungibility 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Recognizability 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Cost Efficiency & Capacity 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Supply Integrity 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Settlement Assurance 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6No Single Point of Control 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Rule Auditability 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Forward Security Margin 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6No Invisible Rent 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Resource Proportionality 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
A1<7
privacy_posture: Transparent
identity_model: Pseudonymous
issuance_ethic: Rule-bound (fixed cap)
consensus_cost: PoS (Ouroboros)
governance_model: On-chain vote
autonomy_accountability: Moderate autonomy
|
| Toncoin TON | 5.7 | 5.8 |
5Acceptability & Liquidity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Value Stability 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Usability & Safety 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Portability & Divisibility 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Fungibility 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Recognizability 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Cost Efficiency & Capacity 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Supply Integrity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Settlement Assurance 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5No Single Point of Control 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Rule Auditability 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Forward Security Margin 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5No Invisible Rent 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Resource Proportionality 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
A1<7
B1/B2<7
privacy_posture: Transparent
identity_model: Pseudonymous
issuance_ethic: Rule-bound elastic
consensus_cost: BFT PoS
governance_model: Foundation
autonomy_accountability: Moderate autonomy
|
| Hyperliquid HYPE | 5.3 | 4.8 |
4Acceptability & Liquidity 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Value Stability 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Usability & Safety 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Portability & Divisibility 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Fungibility 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Recognizability 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Cost Efficiency & Capacity 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Supply Integrity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Settlement Assurance 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
2No Single Point of Control 2/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Rule Auditability 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Forward Security Margin 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4No Invisible Rent 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Resource Proportionality 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
A1<7
B1/B2<7
privacy_posture: Transparent
identity_model: Pseudonymous
issuance_ethic: Fixed genesis + buyback/burn
consensus_cost: HyperBFT (~25 validators)
governance_model: Team/foundation
autonomy_accountability: Low autonomy (intervention precedent)
|
| UNUS SED LEO LEO | 4.9 | 4.3 |
3Acceptability & Liquidity 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Value Stability 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Usability & Safety 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Portability & Divisibility 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Fungibility 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Recognizability 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Cost Efficiency & Capacity 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Supply Integrity 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Settlement Assurance 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
1No Single Point of Control 1/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Rule Auditability 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Forward Security Margin 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5No Invisible Rent 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
2Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 2/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Resource Proportionality 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
A1<7
B1/B2<7
privacy_posture: Transparent
identity_model: Pseudonymous
issuance_ethic: Pre-allocated + buyback/burn
consensus_cost: Inherits host chain
governance_model: Institutional (Bitfinex)
autonomy_accountability: High accountability
|
| Canton CC | 4.7 | 5.7 |
3Acceptability & Liquidity 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Value Stability 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Usability & Safety 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Portability & Divisibility 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Fungibility 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Recognizability 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Cost Efficiency & Capacity 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Supply Integrity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
9Settlement Assurance 9/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3No Single Point of Control 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Rule Auditability 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Forward Security Margin 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6No Invisible Rent 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
8Resource Proportionality 8/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
A1<7
B1/B2<7
privacy_posture: Configurable / institutional privacy
identity_model: Verified (permissioned)
issuance_ethic: Burn-mint, no premine
consensus_cost: BFT (Global Synchronizer)
governance_model: Institutional (Canton Foundation)
autonomy_accountability: High accountability
|
| Chainlink LINK | 4.7 | 5.3 |
3Acceptability & Liquidity 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
3Value Stability 3/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Usability & Safety 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Portability & Divisibility 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Fungibility 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Recognizability 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Cost Efficiency & Capacity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5Supply Integrity 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Settlement Assurance 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Resilience, Liveness & Capacity 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4No Single Point of Control 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
6Rule Auditability 6/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Forward Security Margin 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
5No Invisible Rent 5/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
4Capture-Resistant Rule-Change 4/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
7Resource Proportionality 7/10 UNCALIBRATED — v1 expert judgment, no evidence yet. |
— |
UNCAL
A1<7
B1/B2<7
privacy_posture: Transparent
identity_model: Pseudonymous
issuance_ethic: Pre-allocated
consensus_cost: Oracle network (on ETH)
governance_model: Institutional (Chainlink Labs)
autonomy_accountability: Accountability-leaning
|
Score markers: ~ = speculative (open research problem; score is a ceiling, not current reality) · ● = buildable (technology exists, not yet deployed at scale)
Assets marked UNCAL carry UNCALIBRATED expert-judgment estimates, awaiting v4 re-assessment. Adjusting weights changes the ranking, not the underlying scores. Methodology →